Perm url with updates: http://xahlee.org/js/add_comment_system_to_website.html
How to Add a Comment System to Website
Amazon Kindle. Read books under the sun. Review
Xah Lee, 2010-10-16
Here's some of the pages that's got comment already.
- Emacs Does Not Support Viewing Images Files In Windows
- ErgoEmacs Keybinding
- Beastie Fucking Tux
- Java Tutorial: The “extend” Keyword
- Perl-Python Tutorial: Splitting a Line by Regex
- Chinese Input with Dvorak Layout (Microsoft Pinyin IME)
- Microsoft IntelliType Common Questions
XahLee.org has been static html for 10 years. But with comment, my experience is that it may increase traffic 10 fold.
A Little History on Website Comments and Technology
Comment started in late 1990s. By early 2000s, blog became popular, and comment follows. Many mainstream news websites such as CNN, Time mag, started to let users add comments in all their articles. Though, it is considered experimental. Some organization embraced it, some still take a watch and see stance. Some show comments on the same page, while others show comments in a separate page, still others, make a selected few comments on the article page.
By now, almost all websites have comments.
I never wanted comments. Because, when you look at the comments, some perhaps 95% of it is useless drivel, factually incorrect info, or uninformed opinion. However, from business point of view, it is good. It seems that people like it. People want to be able to input their opinions. For example, if you read a article and thought it's biased bullshit, you probably want to say it. Also, comments increase your site traffic significantly, perhaps 10 fold or 100 fold. Because, when people leave comment, others may not agree and left a reply. So, users came back to the site, sometimes to argue, sometimes to see what others say, or otherwise just to keep informed on any developments. When good comments hits the article, the article author may correct his article, or add input from useful comments, and that almost always happens when there are a lot comments, because nobody can write a article that's 100% perfect, correct, or non-biased.
But still, i didn't see much of the positive points. Mostly what i see is the 95% drivel. The content on XahLee.org is mostly academic articles and tutorials on math and programing. I kinda considered it more like writing a book. And it is a pure hobby, a love of sorts. And i am kinda haughty. My thoughts were, if i let reader comment, then wouldn't it rather distract my readers? Because, my site's pages with very informative article, expositions, essays, would be infested with a whole bunch of random, pot-shot, thoughts. I took the old fashioned approach. That when people want to comment, if they are serious, they could easily write a email to me, then if i find it interested, i edit my article with credit to the person. However, this approach is inefficient. I realized that, there's lots emails i have to go thru, to reply to, with this one-to-one email exchanges. It easily takes a a few hours a week, and often i just didn't have time. Also, 99% who otherwise would comment with valuable info will not bother with the trouble to actually fire up their email to write it. It needs to be spontaneous and painless.
In early 2010, i started to monetize my website. And thought about adding comments. But the problem was that i haven't looked into how i can do that on the tech aspect. So, in the beginning i simply tried to manually mirror any new articles to Blogger, and put a link to the blogger version from my website. So that, those who want to comment can follow the link to Blogger and post there. But this is not a good solution, because it's a extra link, comments doesn't show in the same domain. This is not what people want. Alternative solution is to switch my entire site of 4k static html pages into PHP, or a CMS system such as WordPress. I've been wanting to look into WordPres but never got around to it. But then i discovered Disqus, and it works really well.